Who owns a remix
64 · · 23 min read · Español
A remix is a derivative work twice over — of the recording it is built on and of the song inside that recording — so nobody owns a remix outright. The remixer owns the copyright in what they added and nothing underneath it. The master’s owner keeps every sound that was already there. The writers keep the song. And each of those people has to have said yes in writing, or the remixer’s copyright reaches nothing built on the part they borrowed. Who ends up holding the remix is decided by one document, and the clause most templates lead with does not do it.
- A remix is a derivative work of the sound recording and of the musical work it embodies. Under US law a sound recording’s owner holds the exclusive right to prepare a derivative in which the recording’s actual sounds are rearranged, remixed or otherwise altered; under Canadian law a remix reproduces a substantial part of the recording and of the song, and both need the owner’s authorisation.
- The copyright in a remix extends only to the material the remixer contributed. The original recording’s owner keeps the original sounds, and the song’s writers and publishers keep the song. Where the original was used without permission, no copyright reaches the part of the remix built on it.
- Paying for a remix buys the work and, usually, permission to release it. Ownership moves only by a signed assignment. A work-made-for-hire clause does not make a commissioned remix the commissioner’s, because a remix is on none of the nine categories the statute lists.
- A remixer gets no share of the song by remixing it. New words or melody added to a remix are new authorship of a derivative musical work, owned as the song’s owners agree and protected only with their permission.
- The remix’s copyright owner collects the recording’s royalties and the writers collect the publishing. SoundExchange pays a remixer only through a featured artist’s letter of direction, and the featured artist on a remix is whoever was featured on the recording before it was remixed.
What is a remix, in copyright terms?
A remix is a derivative work: a new sound recording in which the actual sounds of an existing recording are rearranged, remixed or otherwise altered.
The statute has the word. Section 101 defines a derivative work as “a work based upon one or more preexisting works, such as a translation, musical arrangement, dramatization, fictionalization, motion picture version, sound recording, art reproduction, abridgment, condensation, or any other form in which a work may be recast, transformed, or adapted,” and adds that “a work consisting of editorial revisions, annotations, elaborations, or other modifications which, as a whole, represent an original work of authorship” is one too. Then section 114(b) says it in the only sentence of the Act that uses the verb: the sound recording owner’s derivative right “is limited to the right to prepare a derivative work in which the actual sounds fixed in the sound recording are rearranged, remixed, or otherwise altered in sequence or quality.” That is the remix, described by the people who wrote the rules for it, in 1976, before anyone had made one on a laptop.
The Copyright Office draws the floor. Circular 56 calls the result a derivative sound recording — “an audio recording that incorporates preexisting sounds” in which “the preexisting recorded sounds must be rearranged, remixed, or otherwise altered in sequence or character, or the recording must contain additional new sounds,” and “the new or revised sounds must contain at least a minimum amount of original sound recording authorship.” Its examples are “a mashup comprising tracks and sounds from multiple sources” and “additional tracks added to a previously published album.” Below the floor: “mechanical changes or processes, such as a change in format, declicking, or noise reduction, generally do not contain enough original authorship to warrant registration.” A remaster is not a remix, and the code already knows that; this page is about what the code refuses to decide.
So every remix has three things in it, and they belong to two copyrights. The original sounds belong to the recording. The song — melody, words, structure — belongs to the musical work, which is a separate copyright with separate owners, and which every recording of it is already a derivative of. And the new material — the edit, the new drums, the pitched vocal, the added bass, the arrangement of all of it — is the remixer’s contribution, sitting on top of both. A remix is a derivative of a derivative, and the arrangement of a song has its own page and its own rules; this one follows the recording.
Canada gets to the same room by a different door. The Copyright Act has no derivative-work category. A remix there is simply a new sound recording that reproduces “any substantial part” of the original — the maker’s sole right under section 18(1) is “to reproduce it in any material form” — and that reproduces the musical work, whose owner holds the sole right under section 3(1) “to produce or reproduce the work or any substantial part thereof in any material form whatever.” No new word for it, and the same three people in the room.
Who owns the remix recording?
The remixer owns the copyright in what they added; the original recording’s owner keeps every sound that was already there.
The rule is one sentence of section 103(b), and the arranger’s page quotes it for the song side: the copyright in a derivative work extends only to the material its author contributed, as distinguished from the preexisting material, and implies no exclusive right in that material. The second sentence is the one to keep for the recording side — the derivative’s copyright “is independent of, and does not affect or enlarge the scope, duration, ownership, or subsistence of, any copyright protection in the preexisting material.” The remix is a new copyright. It is the remixer’s. It is the size of the remixer’s contribution and not one sample larger. Replace the drums, the bass, the key, the tempo and the structure, and what you own is the drums, the bass, the key, the tempo and the structure.
Who the remixer is, in the statute’s eyes, follows from who authors any recording. Circular 56: “The author of a sound recording is the performer featured in the recording and the producer who captured and processed the sounds that appear in the final recording.” On a remix the featured performance is preexisting material — it was fixed once, in the original, and the remix reuses that fixation rather than capturing a new one — so the person who captured and processed the new recording is the remixer, alone. The joint-authorship question the original had, between the singer and the producer who tracked them, does not arise on the remix, because the singer did nothing new on it. The remixer is the author, and what the remixer authored is the new material.
The Office’s own form is that rule drawn as boxes. Circular 56 again: “When registering a derivative sound recording, identify the preexisting material in the ‘material excluded’ field and identify the new material in the ‘new material included’ field.” Two fields, one for what was already somebody’s and one for what is now yours. Fill the second honestly, because the first is where the original’s owner lives, and no registration moves them out.
Then the sentence above it, which is the one that matters when nobody asked. Section 103(a): protection for a work using preexisting copyrighted material “does not extend to any part of the work in which such material has been used unlawfully.” A remix built on a recording without its owner’s permission has a copyright that reaches none of the part built on it. What is left is whatever the remixer made that stands on its own — a synth line, a drum pattern, a new vocal — and not the remix. The section further down takes that case whole.
Canada answers the ownership half with a word. The first owner of copyright in a sound recording is its maker — section 24 — and the maker is “the person by whom the arrangements necessary for the first fixation of the sounds are undertaken.” For a remix, the sounds being fixed for the first time are the remix’s, so whoever made those arrangements is its maker; the test has its own page, and the next section says what it does to a remix somebody paid for. What the word does not do is reach the original. The original maker’s right to reproduce their recording, and the performer’s own copyright in the performance the remix reuses, both still bind the new recording. Owning the remix in Canada is owning a recording you needed two other people’s permission to make.
If you paid for the remix, do you own it?
Only if the remixer assigned the remix to you in a signed writing; paying for a remix buys the work, not the copyright.
Three deals get called “paying for a remix,” and the piece on paying a producer already sorted them: a fee, a fee plus a royalty, or a share of the thing itself. Only the third was ever about ownership, and even it needs paper. A copyright moves in exactly one way — a signed writing, section 204(a) in the United States, section 13(4) in Canada — and an invoice is not one. Without it, what the money bought is the files and a permission: the remixer made the recording, delivered it, and by delivering it let you release it. A licence. A good one, probably. Not the copyright.
The clause the template leads with does not change that. A work made for hire has two routes under section 101 — an employee within the scope of employment, or a commissioned work that falls into one of nine listed categories and is agreed in a signed writing to be one — and the recording page walks the list, the year Congress put sound recordings on it and the year Congress took them off. A remix is on that list no more than a recording is. One honest wrinkle: a remix delivered for a remix EP or a compilation can be argued to be “a contribution to a collective work,” which is on the list, and Circular 56 itself names “a compilation or contribution to a collective work” as the case where a written agreement makes the commissioning party the author. It is the same unsettled argument the recording page flags for an album track, and it is a thin place to stand a catalogue.
So the sentence that does the work is the assignment — the remixer hereby assigns to you all right, title and interest in and to the remix — and it is the sentence a template built for producers usually carries as a fallback, after a work-for-hire clause that does nothing here. Fuck the template. Write the sentence. Then write what it covers: the remix as delivered, the stems the remixer made, or both, because a remixer who assigns the mix and keeps the stems has assigned a recording and kept its parts. Which instrument says which thing is its own comparison.
Canada tilts the default toward the person who paid, and only tilts it. The remix’s maker is whoever undertook the arrangements for its first fixation, and a commissioning party who booked the remixer, paid them and directed the delivery has a stronger claim to that word than a US commissioning party has to authorship — the producer page walks the test, including the case where the producer’s own studio and initiative make the producer the maker. A remix made on the remixer’s machine, on the remixer’s schedule, for a fee, can come out either way. A signed assignment removes the question in both countries, and it costs one line.
Where the release then goes out is already decided by the distributor’s form. DistroKid’s remix page has a row for “a remix of your own song by a remixing artist” — your account, the remixer added “as a collaborator with the ‘Remixer’ role” — and a row for “a remix of another artist’s music,” which “must have permission from the original artist” and lists “the original artist’s name in the ‘Artist/band name’ section.” Whose account carries the release is the form’s way of asking whose recording it is. How the stores then display the remixer is a credit question, and credits transfer nothing.
Does the remixer get any of the song?
No. A remix leaves the song’s writers and publishers where they were; a remixer gets a share only for new composition the owners agreed to.
Section 103(b) does the same job on the song that it did on the recording. A remix that rearranges sounds — new drums under the same vocal, a new key, a new tempo, a different structure of the same parts — adds nothing to the musical work, so the musical work’s owners are unchanged and the remixer is nobody on it. The code says so from the other side: a remix keeps the original song’s ISWC, because the song did not change. And where a remix does touch the song, the arranger’s rule applies whole: arranging a protected song needs its owners’ permission, no society publishes a default share for it, and what the arranger gets is what the agreement says.
The case that looks like an exception is the remix with a new verse in it. A new topline, a new hook, a rapped verse over the original — those are new words and new melody, and new words and melody are authorship of a derivative musical work. The person who wrote them is an author of what they wrote and of nothing underneath it, on section 103(b) again; whether what they added was authorship at all is the usual test; the share is whatever the song’s owners agree, and the instrument that records it is the usual one. Without the owners’ permission, section 103(a) applies to the song exactly as it applies to the recording: the new verse may be its writer’s, and the song it was written over is not, and the two cannot be separated on a stream.
One more thing the song needs. A remix is a new recording of the song, so it takes its own mechanical licence — the one The MLC administers in the United States. Section 115(a)(1)(B) refuses the compulsory licence for phonorecords “duplicating a sound recording fixed by another” — the map quotes the refusal — “unless … the making of the phonorecords was authorized by the owner of the copyright in the sound recording.” So with the master owner’s yes in hand, the compulsory route to the song is open, on one condition the same section sets: the arrangement “shall not change the basic melody or fundamental character of the work,” and the two-copyrights piece quotes that clause in full. A remix that keeps the melody and swaps everything under it is inside the licence. A remix that rewrites the melody, or adds the verse above, is outside it, and needs the publisher’s express consent — which is the permission the master owner cannot give you, because they do not hold it.
Who gets paid when the remix plays?
The remix’s owner collects the recording’s royalties, the writers and publishers collect the publishing, and a remixer is paid what the remix agreement says.
The master side pays whoever holds the remix’s copyright, through whatever account delivered it — the map of streams has one collector per row and the remix takes the recording rows. The song side pays the writers and publishers of the song, unchanged: the PRO on performance, The MLC on the mechanical, exactly as on the original. The remixer is paid what the agreement says — a fee, a royalty on the remix, or a share of it — and no statute pays a remixer anything for being one. Points and the base they are calculated on work the same way for a remixer as for a producer, and are that page’s.
SoundExchange is where this bites, because the statute names its payees and a remixer is none of them. The featured artists’ share goes to the artists featured on the recording, and on a remix that is whoever was featured on the recording before the remixer touched it. A remixer is paid from that share only if that artist signs it over. SoundExchange’s own page defines a letter of direction as the document “by which a Featured Artist directs SoundExchange to pay a portion of the Featured Artist’s sound recording performance royalties to a participant involved in the creative process – producers, engineers, mixers, re-mixers, etc.,” says such a letter “cannot be used to direct payments to other third parties,” and says SoundExchange “does not pay Creative Participants ‘off the top,’ i.e., prior to allocating royalties to the Featured Artist(s).” Read that as a remixer: your statutory money is a percentage of somebody else’s, signed over by them, or it is nothing. Apple’s vocabulary agrees — the glossary the engineering page quotes lists the Remixer among contributors not heard on the content. In Canada the statutory money divides between the performer’s half and the maker’s half, on that page’s split, and the remixer is in the maker’s half only if the remixer is the maker.
One more place ownership shows up as money. YouTube’s Content ID rules open with “you must have exclusive rights to the material in the reference file for the territories where you claim ownership,” and the first thing on its list of what is ineligible is “content licensed non-exclusively from a third party.” A remixer who holds permission holds exactly that. The remix can be a reference — for whoever owns it. Permission puts a recording on Spotify; it does not put it in Content ID.
What if nobody said yes?
An unauthorised remix infringes both the recording owner’s and the song owner’s rights, and the remixer’s copyright does not reach the borrowed part.
Two rights are crossed at once. Preparing a derivative work is the owner’s exclusive right under section 106(2) — for the recording, in the shape section 114(b) gives it, and for the song, in full — and the master page lists it among the four things an owner can refuse. Then section 103(a) does what it does. The bootlegger has made a recording they cannot register as a whole, cannot license, cannot sell and cannot claim, which the original’s owner can have taken down anywhere it appears and cannot use either, because the new material is still the remixer’s. Nobody owns a bootleg remix. Two people own the parts, and neither can move the whole.
The distributors say the same thing at the door. DistroKid: “you will require permission to do so from all concerned parties,” “it is not possible to upload songs with uncleared samples,” and “if your remix is of another artist’s song or contains any part of another artist’s original music, streaming services require permission from the original artist.” The cover-song form is not the way around it, and the cover piece says why in one line: a remix is not a cover, whatever the form offers to call it.
Canada has one door the United States does not, and it is narrower than it looks. Section 29.21 makes it not an infringement for an individual to use a published work “in the creation of a new work or other subject-matter in which copyright subsists,” and to use it or “authorize an intermediary to disseminate it,” on four conditions: the use is “done solely for non-commercial purposes”; the source and, where given, the author, performer or maker are mentioned “if it is reasonable in the circumstances to do so”; the individual “had reasonable grounds to believe” the original was not itself infringing; and the use “does not have a substantial adverse effect, financial or otherwise, on the exploitation or potential exploitation of the existing work … including that the new work or other subject-matter is not a substitute for the existing one.” Parliament legalised the bedroom remix right up to the first dollar. What the section does not do is the whole of this page: it authorises nothing commercial, it gives the remixer no right anyone else has to respect, and the moment a distributor is involved, condition (a) is gone.
The United States has no section like it. A remix nobody cleared is either an infringement or a fair use, fair use is decided case by case, and no sentence here predicts a case.
What goes in the remix agreement?
Who owns the remix and by which instrument, what the remixer is paid, the credit, approval, and a warranty that the song’s owners consented.
Hold the paper against this list, whichever side of it you are on.
- The instrument, and what it covers. An assignment or a licence; the remix as delivered, the stems the remixer made, or both. A licence names its territory and its term. An assignment names nothing, because it is everything.
- The money. A fee, a royalty and the base it is calculated on, or a share of the remix — and, for statutory money, whether the featured artist will sign a letter of direction, because nothing else pays a remixer at SoundExchange.
- The credit. As the stores will display it, in the words the delivery form uses.
- Approval and the account. Who approves the mix, and whose distributor account releases it.
- The song. Who cleared it — and the master owner’s warranty that they hold the right to authorise a derivative of the recording, which is a different right from owning the recording.
- The remixer’s own material. If the deal is an assignment, a licence back to the remixer for the elements they made from nothing, so a drum pattern does not leave with the mix.
- The grant’s lifetime. A derivative made under a grant survives that grant’s later termination, which is why a label’s remix of a song outlives the songwriter’s recovery of the song.
Then the three columns, for every remix in the catalogue: whose sounds, whose song, whose paper. Most of the rows fill themselves — your sounds, your song, no paper needed. The rows with someone else in the first two columns need something in the third, and the row with an empty third column is the one this page was about. The audit checklist has a line for it. Where counsel comes from is one page and what they do with a remix agreement is another.
This week: pull every remix you have released or delivered, and write the three columns for each. The remix you commissioned with an invoice and a handshake is a recording you can release and do not own. The remix you delivered for a fee and a work-for-hire clause is a recording you still own and have already let go. Both are fixed by one signed sentence, and the sentence is cheaper now than after the record does well.
FAQ
Do I need permission to remix my own song?
Not if you own all of the master and all of the song. If a producer, a co-writer, a publisher or a label owns any share of either, a remix reproduces their copyright too, and whether one co-owner can license it alone differs between the United States and Canada: a US co-owner can grant a non-exclusive licence and owes the others an accounting, and in Canada the default is the consent of every co-owner. Both defaults have their own page.
Does a remix need its own ISRC?
Yes. A remix is a new recording and takes its own ISRC, on the ISRC Handbook’s rules. The song inside it did not change, so the song’s ISWC does not change either: one work code, one more recording code against it. The version decision and the work code each have a page.
Is a DJ mix or a mashup owned differently from a remix?
No. A DJ mix and a mashup are derivative sound recordings on the same rules as a remix: the person who made the mix owns the selection, the sequence and any new sounds, every source recording’s owner keeps their recording, and every source needs to have said yes. YouTube will not accept a continuous DJ mix or a mashup as a Content ID reference even where every source is owned outright.
Can I register a remix I made without permission?
Not the part built on the borrowed recording. The statute says protection does not extend to any part of a work in which preexisting material was used unlawfully, and the Copyright Office’s own form asks you to exclude the preexisting material and name what is new. Anything you wrote or played that stands on its own is yours; the remix as a thing people would listen to is not.
Sources
- 17 U.S.C. § 101 (Cornell LII) — the definitions of a derivative work, both sentences; of sound recordings; and of a work made for hire, with its two routes and nine categories.
- 17 U.S.C. § 103 — (a): no protection for any part of a work in which preexisting material has been used unlawfully; (b): the copyright in a derivative work extends only to the material its author contributed, implies no exclusive right in the preexisting material, and is independent of and does not affect the copyright in it.
- 17 U.S.C. § 106 — (2): the exclusive right to prepare derivative works based upon the copyrighted work.
- 17 U.S.C. § 114 — (b): the sound recording owner’s derivative right is limited to a derivative in which the actual sounds fixed in the recording are rearranged, remixed or otherwise altered in sequence or quality.
- 17 U.S.C. § 115 — (a)(1)(B): no compulsory licence for phonorecords duplicating a sound recording fixed by another unless the recording was fixed lawfully and the making of the phonorecords was authorised by the owner of copyright in the sound recording; (a)(2): the arrangement privilege and its limit.
- US Copyright Office, Circular 56, Copyright Registration for Sound Recordings (PDF) — the definition of a derivative sound recording, its two examples and its floor; that the author of a sound recording is the featured performer and the producer who captured and processed the sounds; the compilation or contribution-to-a-collective-work case for a work made for hire; and the “material excluded” and “new material included” fields. Read from the PDF, decoded locally; the body text decoded cleanly, the numeral font used for footnotes and the revision date did not, so no revision date is stated here and nothing is quoted from a footnote.
- SoundExchange, Letters of Direction — a letter of direction as the document by which a featured artist directs payment to a creative participant, naming producers, engineers, mixers and re-mixers; that a letter cannot direct payment to other third parties; that creative participants are not paid off the top.
- DistroKid, Uploading DJ Mixes or Remixes to DistroKid (updated 2026-09-09) — permission from all concerned parties; no uncleared samples; streaming services require the original artist’s permission for a remix of another artist’s music; the form’s three cases and the Remixer role; that remixes are not cover songs.
- YouTube Help, Qualifying for Content ID — the exclusive-rights requirement for a reference file; content licensed non-exclusively from a third party as ineligible; continuous DJ mixes and mashups as ineligible references.
- Copyright Act (Canada), s. 2 — the definition of maker: for a sound recording, the person by whom the arrangements necessary for the first fixation of the sounds are undertaken.
- Copyright Act (Canada), s. 3 — (1): copyright in a work as the sole right to produce or reproduce the work or any substantial part of it in any material form, including, for a musical work, to make any sound recording of it.
- Copyright Act (Canada), s. 18 — (1): the maker’s sole right, in relation to the sound recording or any substantial part of it, to publish it for the first time, to reproduce it in any material form and to rent it out, and to authorise those acts.
- Copyright Act (Canada), s. 24 — the first owner of copyright in a sound recording is the maker.
- Copyright Act (Canada), s. 29.21 — non-commercial user-generated content: the exception and its four conditions, quoted above.
Every page cited here was read on the date at the top of this piece. One source is a PDF read through a local decoder rather than as text, and the piece says so beside the citation. A change in how SoundExchange treats remixers that trade press reported in 2023 is not asserted here, because no SoundExchange page states it; only what SoundExchange’s own page says today is on this page. Nothing here is legal advice, and whether an unauthorised remix’s new elements are protectable at all is a question this page leaves to a court, on purpose.
Keeping the register
The three columns are the whole discipline: whose sounds, whose song, whose paper, for every version of every track. CatalogTracker keeps a remix as its own track beside the original, with its own ISRC, version and recording type; keeps master splits and publishing splits per track and separately, each summing to its own 100, so the remix’s master column can differ from the original’s while the writer column stays what it was; and an agreement uploaded beside the splits is hashed and flagged when the splits or a party changed after it was signed. In development for iPhone.